The dualclutch transmission is a wonderful option on the golf gti, but. Hi, im new here, and i this thread is probably somewhere, but after a bit of searching i couldnt find it, so if someone could point me to it, thatd be great, if it really doesnt exist, well here it is and i am surprised. Volkswagen made the dualclutch transmission an option on the gti and golf r. Volkswagen golf gti dsg v volkswagen golf gti manual61. David zalstein and tony crawford tackle the question using one of the worlds best and most. So, as the title suggests, which one should i go for. The gti is based on volkswagens popular golf, and the wrx is based on the subaru impreza. Dsg is just a preferenceoptions and weather its better than manual or. E and dspecific features include chequered upholstery, a sports steering wheel and, ah yes, in the manual gti, a golf ball.
In fact i go as far as saying more than half the golf r cars local to me in my price range were dsg. With precision craftsmanship and a 228hp turbocharged engine, theres no wonder why the 2020 golf gti is referred to as the golf hot hatch. Hi my girlfriend and i have decided to get a car and weve chosen to get a 2015 gti, but were not sure about the transmission. Maybe the issue is when comparing the dsgstronic to the manual audi s4 or gti or golf r etc, since those vwgroup manuals are all a bit on the clunky side, with long throws. I found the dsg to be very technically capable, quick, responsive, etc. It can act exactly the way you want it to in any situation and its very smart. The focus st was refreshed in 2015, the golf gti in 2016.
Jan 12, 2018 4 can generally handle more power than a standards clutch, at least for mk6 gti s 5 paddle shifters im not saying a dsg is better than a manual, as i love my rabbit and miatas manual. With firm control, the golf gti can stay level in corners and help maintain grip while managing to provide a smooth ride. In this article, well compare the focus st vs gti with the assumption that youre looking at the used market. Also, my girlfriend sort of knows how to drive manual but not comfortably enough to drive on the roads, so shes not 100% in and obviously cant be that she wants a stick.
Ive driven several dsg golfs r32s and a chipped diesel and i think the box is amazing. Strictly speaking, this is an automated manual, but it can shift gears itself or allow manual selection either by moving the lever or using steeringwheelmounted paddles. Id like to hear the pros and cons of each transmission from. This dsg doesnt feel much like a manual when you climb behind the wheel and clock a familiar auto gearstick, complete with p, r, n and d markings. I assume this is related to supply and demand, as most people choose auto i think.
Nov 12, 2016 you can have arguably the best golf ever for. Our two test cars for the day will be a carbon steel grey manual and a tornado red dsg. While i think it is certainly a good idea that the 2015 volkswagen golf gti offers an automatic transmission option, there is absolutely. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti. While i think it is certainly a good idea that the 2015 volkswagen golf gti offers an automatic transmission option, there. Early estimates for 060 mph have placed the gti at around five and a half seconds with the dsg, as we expect the engine to feel underrated like previous generation cars.
But just as the new seventhgeneration golf exists in many forms, there are many flavors of gti, too, all of which are worth knowing. Dsg is just a preferenceoptions and weather its better than manual or not is relative. Manual mode on dsg is way more fun and engaging than true manual. Now, though, i reckon buying a manual is like buying a television that has no remote control. My primary reason for wanting auto was to make long journeys in heavy traffic more comfortable. Next article great drag race rs 3 vs a45 amg vs civic type r vs golf r vs focus rs. A switch from a manualor even dsg gti which holds each gear longer and has a lot longer rev range to a dsg tdi will definitely. Dsg vs manual vw gti mkvi forum vw golf r forum vw.
Volkswagens dsg transmission makes it easy not to miss the. Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. Mar 28, 2006 dsg vs manual is abit like, silver vs black. Feb 26, 2020 a sixspeed dsg meshes everything together and sends power forwards. Dsg vs manual vw gti mkvi forum vw golf r forum vw golf. In a performance car like the gti a manual is a must. I didnt test drive anything when coming to this, my first, golf but i knew all along that whatever car i got it was going to be automatic after 20 years of driving manual. Ultimately, we wouldnt fault anyone for choosing the dsg over the manual, or vice versa.
The mk7 golf comes with a 6speed automatic instead of a dsg. Although vws dsg dualclutch automated manual is a good, reasonably sporty automatic, it is still an automatic. The most formidable is the longrunning volkswagen golf gti. In fact, if you were buying a golf r, i would suggest you buy that over the manual. Aug 28, 2018 the mk7 golf comes with a 6speed automatic instead of a dsg. I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. Aug 18, 2017 golf gti vs golf r which looks better. I spend most of my commute in traffic on the m25 where an auto would be very nice, but. Amazing in that u cannot feel the gear changes up or down only feel it change from 1st to 2nd, amazing that under full throttle accelaration, there is no pause in g force as it changes gear. Comparing the mazda 3 to the vw golf, two small hatchbacks with manual transmissions that compete at the affordable end of the newcar spectrum. If you like keeping a low profile, then both the volkswagen golf gti and golf r are hot hatches that specialise in anonymity. Depreciation depreciation is an estimate of the reduction in value incurred by owning and operating a vehicle over a period of time. Honestly, coming from a dsg owner, id wait until you find a. Jul 02, 2019 comparing the mazda 3 to the vw golf, two small hatchbacks with manual transmissions that compete at the affordable end of the newcar spectrum.
Plus you also need to factor in the maintenance costs of the dsg in 10k miles since dsg fluid service is at 40k. I am considering purchasing a 2019 gti, most likely the rabbit edition. At gti international i went up against a stock manual gti in my stock dsg gti and i won. Aug 05, 2010 the dsg always short shifts in d mode for improved efficiency and hardly makes use of the first gear. The volkswagen gti and subaru wrx are two established nameplates in the compact car segment. The dsg has a different feel then a traditional torque converter style automatic. Nov 22, 2018 with the old polo gti, there were two benefits to a manual gearbox, as the 7speed dsg couldnt handle all the torque of the 1. The volkswagen golf gti is one of the most wellrounded sporty cars you can buy today. Ford focus st vs vw golf gti comparison cj pony parts. Alright, so back when i was looking around i tried the mk6 and mk7 of both the gti and golf r, with a mix of the dsg and 6mt transmissions. Volkswagens dsg transmission makes it easy not to miss. Jul 05, 2019 the volkswagen golf gti is one of the most wellrounded sporty cars you can buy today.
It is a very advanced transmission, with positives and negatives. Have you driven a golf or sportwagen with the dsg yet. We go for a drive in the 2019 vw gti rabbit support us on patreon. Vw golf r dsg v manual video 12 may 2010 they main problem with the manual, in this rather pointless 060 exercise, is that second gear doesnt take you to 60, which is a bit odd. The gear changing speed in the dsg is quick enough to compensate for the reduced torque. That being said, i only want a miata even more now. Dsg or manual, what would you do page 1 general gassing. New polo gti manual is for purists iol breaking news. One of the main reasons i got a dsg box was due to the gear knob, on the manual box, looking as if it was straight out of halfords.
I want to buy a dualclutch volkswagen golf, but will its. Some buyers may appreciate how undertheradar aesthetics can be married to such a rapid mode of family transport, but others may prefer something a bit more extrovert. The r32 is basically the golf to get, we all know that. The dsg owner facing potentially high maintenance costs if things go wrong. The 2019 volkswagen golf gti adds a special rabbit edition for the new model year, as well as a new sevenspeed automatic transmission in place of. The depreciation cost is calculated using a combination of data sources and assumptions. The 7th generation or mk 7 vw gti is one of the closest matches to the focus sts size, performance, and price. The dsg always short shifts in d mode for improved efficiency and hardly makes use of the first gear. The r32 is basically the golf to get, we all know that, theres no. A sixspeed dsg meshes everything together and sends power forwards. Buying myself a golf gti mk5 in the next few weeks to commute in and cant decide between a manual or a dsg. I am currently driving a gti 5 and s40 t5 and i know what i want except that i am not sure whether dsg or manual. An acquaintance who runs a vw tuning place has strongly recommended a manual over a dsg box, describing the semiauto as a potential box of pain if there are any problems, as opposed to a manual which is easier to maintain and cheaper to repair. As fun as it is functional, the gti is the kind of hot hatchback you can wring out on the weekend but happily.
The capabilities that you get between normal drive. Both cars are highperformance versions of valueoriented models. With the old polo gti, there were two benefits to a manual gearbox, as the 7speed dsg couldnt handle all the torque of the 1. Manual transmissions are an absolute joy, but the dsg is capable of much more than you or me. Considering a subaru wrx sti, ford focus rs, honda civic type r, mercedesamg. This dsg doesnt feel much like a manual when you climb behind the wheel and clock a familiar auto gearstick, complete with p. Manual v dsg grapschknutsch 14th apr 2018 im very curious, why nobody compares acceleration with a certain rpm limit like staying below 3000 or 4000rpm. In conclusion, the dsg transmission makes the gti into the ultimate daily driver. Manual transmissions are an absolute joy, but the dsg is. Oct 09, 2018 the gti is frontwheeldrive only, and a 6speed manual transmission is standard.